121 years ago City beat United in a Cup Final, no history?

Ok so technically it wasn't Manchester City against Manchester United but it was both their previous incarnations with Ardwick AFC (City) beating Newton Heath (later United) 1-0 in the Manchester Senior Cup on this day 121 years ago. And they say we have no history!

For many sides in the Manchester area this was an important competition. For Ardwick and Newton Heath it was more important competition probably than even the FA Cup. For Ardwick to reach the final was a major landmark for the team who were still relatively young. 

The competition itself had only been established seven years earlier and three years in a new trophy was commissioned at an expense of 60 Guineas (1.05 pounds or $1.67 in todays money). That trophy is still contested today with the Manchester City reserves picking it up in 2010, 2007, 2005 and 2001. In the 1970's it changed from senior teams into amateur and non league sides. From 1980 through to 1998 the competition wasn't held but was reintroduced as a reserve team competition for the six professional clubs.  

It was actually the City secretary-manager Lawrence Furniss who was the visionary behind the development of Ardwick's progression and later development into Manchester City and he saw the Manchester Cup as a significant first step.

Furniss is one major player in the reason Manchester City is even a club right now. He started off in the congregation of St Marks and played for the church team. A knee injury cut short his career but the loss on the field was a big gain off it in footballs backroom. For example he was a key player in the development and move to first Hyde and then Maine Road. With the fans at the time insisting that the latter ground be named after Mr Furniss in recognition of what he had done. 

In 1899 he became the Secretary-Manager of Ardwick and his leadership took the club to a whole other level. First, only to years after he took charge, Ardwick had won the Manchester Cup. The winning of this then allowed them to join the Football Alliance League (effectively a Division 2). Furniss had his heart set on being introduced into the higher league (Football League) but that wasn't the case. He didn't have to wait long though as his first season in the Alliance League got him promotion to the top division. This made him, at least up until Peter Reid came along 100 years later, the clubs youngest League manager. 

Back to the match though and Ardwick actually won the game early on with what was described in the local paper of the time as a 'long shot' after seven minutes from David Weir. Ardwick did have the ball in the back of the net again shortly after the opening goal but it was disallowed. I know what you are thinking, Howard Webbs great-great-grandfather? Nope, it was a free kick delivered directly into the net, the only problem was it was actually an 'indirect' freekick. Maybe they were hoping for a touch or maybe the rules were just so new that players had forgotten. Who knows however, I remember the introduction of the backpass being funny as goalkeepers automatically picked up the ball in the early seasons. 

Ardwicks nickname at the time was the 'Brewerymen' back then and funnily enough Newton Heath still had eyes on the evil side, nicknamed the 'Heathens'. Now as United, they are the Red Devils. Ardwick would retain the trophy the following season, this time against Bolton. It was then that it was decided that the club could go one of two ways, either they would continue to play local sides for local trophies or go bigger. Opinions were split but in the end it was decided that the City needed a club to represent them as a whole and so the end of the 1893-94 season Ardwick was no more and Manchester City rose from the ashes and the rest is history.

PA Cityboy

  For more Football Blogs and opinion from football fans around the world

Comments

[Harrison]

Of course city have a history, just a crap one compared to United who are much more of a special club respected all over the world for its football. United has made manchester a famous city around the planet.

[J4ckBl4ck]

@Harrison

United gained that fame on the back of a tragedy that they've been milking the arse
out of ever since it happened.That brought the fame,shame the atrocious treatment
of the survivors wasn't as widely publicised. That's YOUR history pal.

[CiTyBlUe]

United may be loved around the world by the easily pleased and narrow minded, but they are not loved around Manchester because Manchester City are the pride of Manchester.

At least Manchester City have Manchester and a home, all United have is a lie of a name and adopted homes around the world.

United are like a camper van full of in breds travelling around the world begging for love.

[Dennis Has Done It]

@ Harrison
United is a bigger club, granted. However, City does have lots of history. First Manchester team to win major honours for a start (United followed suit not long after when they pilfered all City's great players of the day, due to a 'slight hiccup' at the club). Also, didn't City achieve something in the late 60s and early 70s? How did United do in the 70s and 80s, by the way? Did they pick up bucket loads of trophies, prior to the inauguration of the Premier League?

In any case, if being the most supported and 'special' club in, say, Singapore, is all that important to you, then well done, sir!

@ J4ckBl4ck
Though this statement carries an element of truth, it is not entirely true. Manchester United was already one of the biggest and best supported clubs around. The 'disaster' that you speak of, merely propelled their 'following' to unparalleled levels.

@ CityBlue
Now that's just not true, is it. However, the club should be named Salford United, granted.

Anyway, to the point.
A well written article and a gentle reminder to all Rags that the Blues do have what we may call 'history'. In fact, Manchester itself can be proud of its footballing heritage. Who could argue that the Premier League trophy is going to leave Manchester during the next 20 years? Probably why the Match of the Day crew moved up there (well, Salford, anyway).

So, may the best team win ... as long as it's City!